The registry GSA hoped to use excludes most registered companies

About 95% of the 877,000 companies in GAO’s July 2025 federal-award registration snapshot were U.S.-incorporated. Applying that rounded share produces roughly 833,000 registrations outside Treasury’s beneficial-ownership reporting requirement. The figure describes a historical registry snapshot, not a current count of contractors, fraudsters or paid awards.

What’s the Scoop With Broach compared GAO’s underlying registry analysis with Treasury’s final rule, effective August 14, 2026. The comparison answers a practical accountability question: a registry that excludes most domestically incorporated entities cannot, by itself, supply comprehensive ownership information for a federal-award population composed overwhelmingly of those entities.

A company’s legal existence, mailing address and corporate parent are different questions from which individual ultimately controls it. A record can establish that a business exists without identifying the person who would benefit from its government contract. That difference is central to this analysis.

Registry coverage comparison; rounded GAO share applied to GAO’s historical company count.
MeasureRecord/calculationMeaning
Companies in GAO’s July 2025 SAM snapshot877,000Registered to do business with the government
U.S.-incorporated shareAbout 95%Exempt under narrowed FinCEN requirement
Approximate exempt registrations, calculatedAbout 833,000877,000 × 0.95; rounded, historical
Non-U.S.-incorporated remainder, calculatedAbout 44,000Not automatically all required to report

Two federal policy choices now pull in different directions

Section 885 of the FY 2021 defense authorization law directed GSA to include beneficial ownership in its federal-award integrity database, to the extent practicable, for awards above $500,000. GAO’s August 31 report says implementation was still awaiting FAR rulemaking and that GSA had contemplated using FinCEN information.

Treasury’s August 11 announcement made the domestic-company exemption permanent and said FinCEN would delete previously reported information reasonably identified as belonging to U.S. persons. Treasury presents the policy as reducing burdens on lawful small businesses without compromising national security. The final rule also retains reporting for covered foreign entities’ foreign owners.

These are distinct requirements. Exemption from FinCEN reporting does not repeal the contractor-database direction. It changes the usefulness of the source GSA had considered. Nor does a lawful reporting exemption establish that any exempt company has concealed wrongdoing.

Risk dollars cannot be converted into a fraud total

GAO’s award table reports $295 billion for agencies with contracting risks, $177.9 billion in set-asides, $102.6 billion in LLC/LLP contracts, $15.4 billion in contracts to foreign-owned businesses and $8.5 billion in assistance to foreign entities. The categories overlap. Adding them would double-count awards and would still not measure money stolen.

The original finding is a coverage mismatch supported by two public records. Our calculation uses the published rounded share, rather than attempting to reconstruct the sensitive SAM extract. The report dates limit what can be inferred about later rulemaking: it establishes the unresolved implementation described in GAO’s review, not that every October procurement lacks every possible ownership safeguard.

Sources and further reading

GAO-26-108174 full report, published Aug 31 and released Sep 30, 2026 ↗

Treasury permanent BOI-exemption announcement, Aug 11, 2026 ↗

FinCEN final rule, effective Aug 14, 2026 ↗

Treasury photograph and CC BY-SA 4.0 reuse license ↗