A $244,605.50 gap below the engineer's estimate

Kern Public Works estimated $1,261,747.50 for rehabilitation of Rosamond Boulevard between State Route 14 and the Union Pacific Railroad. Griffith Company submitted the lowest of six bids at $1,017,142 and staff recommended the company as responsive and responsible after verifying its license.

The low bid is $244,605.50, or 19.39%, below the estimate. Dobe Construction was second at $1,215,798.20, only 3.64% below the estimate and $198,656.20 above Griffith.

Rosamond Boulevard bids
BidderBid
Griffith$1,017,142.00
Dobe$1,215,798.20
Security Paving$1,252,208.00
Granite$1,392,489.00
Bowman Asphalt$1,434,565.00
Butier Engineering$1,591,333.00
Sources: Rosamond Boulevard bid packet

The six-bid field was widely dispersed

The highest bid exceeded the lowest by $574,191, or 56.45% of the low bid. Three bids were below the county estimate and three were above it. That pattern provides more price evidence than a single-bid procurement, while also showing that contractors priced the same plans very differently.

A low award can reflect competition, contractor capacity, quantity assumptions or risk pricing. The packet does not break out unit-price differences, so it cannot by itself identify which factor produced Griffith's result.

Award price is not final savings

The Scoop transcribed the bid table and recalculated the estimate variance and bid spread. The $244,605.50 difference should not be called realized savings: change orders, quantity changes and closeout claims can alter the final cost.

The accountability test comes at completion. Kern should publish the executed amount, change orders, final quantities and delivery date so residents can compare the low bid with the finished project rather than treating award-day arithmetic as the final result.

Sources and further reading

Kern County November 17 agenda ↗

Rosamond Boulevard rehabilitation bid packet ↗

Antelope Valley photograph and license ↗