The low offer was $276,555 under the estimate
Kern estimated $645,640 to replace two culverts: one on Bena Road west of Bealeville Road and another north of Caliente Bodfish Road. MAC General Engineering bid $369,085. Staff verified the license and recommended award, citing available Local Road Fund money.
The low bid is $276,555, or 42.84%, below the engineer's estimate. It is also $118,671 below the second bid from DOD Construction.
| Bidder | Bid |
|---|---|
| MAC General Engineering | $369,085 |
| DOD Construction | $487,756 |
| Teichert | $497,646 |
| Griffith | $519,640 |
| Granite | $599,978 |
All five bids were below the estimate
Even the highest bid was $45,662 under the estimate. The $230,893 spread between the highest and lowest equals 62.56% of the low bid, a sign that the contractors made materially different assumptions about cost or risk.
The record does not establish that Kern's estimate was defective. Engineer estimates may include contingencies or use different market timing, and the bid tab alone does not disclose unit-price or quantity drivers.
A large award-day gap needs a closeout comparison
This report recalculated every bid against the estimate. The analysis establishes a competitive result at award; it does not establish $276,555 in final savings, workmanship quality or completion on schedule.
Because the percentage gap is large, the county should publish the winning schedule of values, all change orders and final quantities. That comparison would show whether the estimate was conservative, the contractor found efficiencies or later field conditions narrowed the gap.
Sources and further reading
Kern County November 17 agenda ↗
