45.3% of reviewed proposals received a risk flag

Five agencies reported conducting due diligence on 28,162 Small Business Innovation Research and Small Business Technology Transfer proposals in fiscal 2024 and 2025. GAO's combined data show 1,712 proposals flagged for possible foreign risk and 11,048 for another risk area such as patents or cybersecurity.

Together, 12,760 proposals—45.3%—received at least one flag in GAO's mutually exclusive summary categories. A flag is a screening result, not a finding of espionage, fraud or ineligibility.

Agency-reported due-diligence outcomes
CategoryProposalsShare
Possible foreign risk1,7126.1%
Other risk area11,04839.2%
Not flagged15,40254.7%
Total28,162100%
Sources: GAO-27-108923

Agencies use a common disclosure form but different data systems

The Air Force, Department of Energy, National Institutes of Health, NASA and National Science Foundation generally start with a standardized disclosure form, then use analytical tools or counterintelligence review to verify foreign affiliations and financial support. After review, they may award, add mitigation conditions or deny funding.

GAO found the five agencies maintained and tracked due-diligence data through different approaches, including automated systems and spreadsheets. That variation does not prove the decisions were inconsistent, but it complicates comparison across the programs.

What the numbers do—and do not—show

The Scoop divided each GAO category by the 28,162-proposal total and kept foreign and other risk flags separate. The review covers the five largest award-making agencies, not every participating agency, and GAO did not make recommendations in this report.

The next accountability measure is disposition: how many flagged proposals were denied, mitigated, cleared or awarded, how long reviews took and whether later monitoring found violations. Without comparable outcome data, the public can see screening volume but not consistently evaluate whether similar risks produced similar decisions.

Sources and further reading

GAO, Small Business Research Programs ↗

GAO report PDF and underlying figures ↗

CubeRover photograph and public-domain notice ↗